10 replies to this topic

[Red Dough Boy]

Seeing as the AMX Chaffee was bumped up a tier semi recently, the PZ V/IV has no more excuses remaining at tier 5. Give it the 75 L/70, most other stats can remain the same or be buffed to match the bump to tier 6. I have wanted one, but it's also one of the more scummy seal clubbing tanks still in game, and at tier 5 seeing tier 3 new players no less.

 

If people complain they can just know they were dirty seal clubbers that had it coming, and now have to face tanks they can't just always run straight into.

[killer etzi0]

Red Dough Boy, on 20 May 2019 - 09:11 AM, said:

Seeing as the AMX Chaffee was bumped up a tier semi recently, the PZ V/IV has no more excuses remaining at tier 5. Give it the 75 L/70, most other stats can remain the same or be buffed to match the bump to tier 6. I have wanted one, but it's also one of the more scummy seal clubbing tanks still in game, and at tier 5 seeing tier 3 new players no less.

 

If people complain they can just know they were dirty seal clubbers that had it coming, and now have to face tanks they can't just always run straight into.

 

Ahh... most Tier V"s can run "straight" into any Tier III they come across. Although my once beloved T67 got eaten alive by tier III lights.... dagnabit. 

[Pontiac Pat]

The AMX Chaffee was bumped because it caused matchmaking issues.  That's very different from just having too much health for your tier.  All they've ever needed to do to the V/IV is lop a couple hundred health off and it would be just fine.

[AJH387]

Didn't that thing used to have PMM, back in the day? I feel like it did when it was in the Founder's Pack. Anyways, I think it can be OP still but at the same time, it is more easily dealt with now than it ever has been before. The fact that it sees Absolutions, Minutemans etc when it plays up and then Captured KV1's and Churchhill premiums at 5, it to me doesn't stand out as ridiculous. It's pretty much on par with all of those mentioned tanks, throw in the 131 etc. Just my opinion. It barely turns now and the pen is not great. Yes, you can wreck a game rather easily when high tier, but I don't see them breaking the game any more than the other tanks mentioned. 

[HybredXero]

Pontiac Pat, on 20 May 2019 - 10:46 AM, said:

The AMX Chaffee was bumped because it caused matchmaking issues.  That's very different from just having too much health for your tier.  All they've ever needed to do to the V/IV is lop a couple hundred health off and it would be just fine.

 

take that couple hundred health and give it to the AMX Chaffee.  Issues for both tank solved.

[RUNNINGDUDE1]

killer etzi0, on 20 May 2019 - 07:34 AM, said:

 

Ahh... most Tier V"s can run "straight" into any Tier III they come across. Although my once beloved T67 got eaten alive by tier III lights.... dagnabit.

 

Oops. Was that you that I drove circles around in PZ1C and lit you up? If so then

[FRlGHTKNIGHT]

If you don't have one, how do you know how good or bad it is?

[SuperSherman44]

I think we are all beating a dead horse here

[RUNNINGDUDE1]

SuperSherman44, on 20 May 2019 - 04:09 PM, said:

I think we are all beating a dead horse here

 

Literally, metaphorically, and surely (yes, I shouldn't call you Shirley ), we have not beating it hard enough

[killer etzi0]

RUNNINGDUDE1, on 20 May 2019 - 12:47 PM, said:

 

Oops. Was that you that I drove circles around in PZ1C and lit you up? If so then

 

[SuperSherman44]

RUNNINGDUDE1, on 20 May 2019 - 07:45 PM, said:

 

Literally, metaphorically, and surely (yes, I shouldn't call you Shirley ), we have not beating it hard enough